Monday, March 26, 2012

The myth of the speech balloon


I trust that most of you will by now have bought your first day covers of the Royal Mail stamps featuring classic British comics? They really are excellent as is the mini-Dandy No.1 (reprinting 12 of the first issue's 28 pages) and the brief history of comics that accompanies it.


However, there is one little glitch that perpetuates a common myth of British comics. In the folder that comes with the stamps, Graham Kibble-White states "In 1937, DC Thomson launched The Dandy. This landmark title mixed rollicking adventure tales with robust comic strips that featured individual speech balloons rather than text blocks. This innovation made the stories easier to follow and prompted the launch of The Beano in 1938, as well as setting the template for future comics."

It's a mistake that James Chapman also made in his book British Comics, A Cultural History, when he wrote "While they maintained some text stories, Dandy and Beano introduced a new kind of picture strip that dispensed with text captions underneath the pictures and used speech balloons for dialogue."

It's the same myth that was in the BBC Four series Comic Britannia a few years ago. However, the fact is that in December 1937 The Dandy No.1 did not innovate speech balloons in comics, nor was it the first British comic to dispense with text under the panels. Here's a few examples to prove it...

From 1917, twenty years before Dandy No.1, the cover of Picture Fun No.428, with word balloons used in practically every panel...


From 1933, the cover of The Funny Wonder No.1,023, which not only uses speech balloons but also sound effects. (Art by Roy Wilson.)


Inside that same 1933 issue, two strips that use word balloons, dispense with the text under the panels, and even have the sort of rhyming couplets that The Dandy and other DC Thomson comics were known for.



A cover of The Sparkler from July 3rd 1937 (five months before The Dandy was launched) showing word balloons in every panel. (Art by Roy Wilson again.)


That very same week, The Butterfly featured its regular strip Perky, which although features some text it's relegated to the foot of the strip rather than appearing under each panel.


However, in the same issue, this short strip tells the story with word balloons and no text whatsoever...


So, speech balloons and textless strips had been used frequently in British comics long before The Dandy debuted. So how did this myth arise? I'm not sure, but it's one that been doing the rounds for decades and I even believed it myself at one stage. (I may have even written an article or two years ago that's guilty of the same assumption.) It seems to be an error made by some comic historians rather than originating from DC Thomson itself.

Thing is, The Dandy was innovative when it arrived but the reasons why are harder to pin down. For example The Butterfly, Funny Wonder and other comics of the time dispensed with text on some humour strips but The Dandy dispensed with text on most of them. Basically The Dandy took its inspiration from existing British comics and expanded upon it. This gave the impression that The Dandy was a more modern looking and faster paced comic. Also, the tone of The Dandy seemed brasher and not as slick as those from Amalgamated Press. It seemed to have a different attitude than its rival titles, and, yes, that new-kid-on-the-block cockiness did inspire other comics. Perhaps the myth that The Dandy introduced speech balloons to British comics just makes for a simpler soundbite... but it's still wrong.

By the way, despite that, James Chapman's British Comics, A Cultural History is still a cracking read and an absorbing study of the history and sociological significance of comics. Order your copy from Amazon here if you haven't already bought the book.

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

another urban myth... such as teenagers did not exist before rock n roll in the second half of the 1950s.
but i remember reading an article that was published in 1948 that makes reference to teenagers, but unlike you i do not possess the magazine anymore for evidence.

Anonymous said...

my landlady was chatting to me about stan lee - how he invented spider-man and all those other famous comic heroes. this myth is the accepted reality now

SREW said...

Should Mickey Mouse figure in the story here? I always wondered how much the arrival of Mickey Mouse Weekly played a role in the launch/style/success of the Dandy and Beano. Because the title is 'American' it doesn't seem to get much airtime in stories about the history of British comics, but to what extent did MMW set the agenda for publishers, artists, and audiences of the DCT titles? In short, how American were Dandy and Beano in their day? I'd be interested to know your thoughts...

Smurfswacker said...

It's interesting to see how far back speech balloons go (John Adcock has been running some examples from "Punch" in the 1870s).

One thing I still don't understand about the hybrid text/speech comics. Why did the creators repeat the dialogue from the text block in the balloons, often word for word? Did they figure some kids would read the balloons only and others the text?

Lew Stringer said...

That's an excellent point about Mickey Mouse Weekly Srew. The earliest one I have is the 1938 New Year issue, published a month after Dandy No.1, but it would have course have been paginated before the publishers saw the Dandy. And yes, it features several strips that have no text captions and all have word balloons, and no doubt earlier issues were the same.

Yes, I think The Dandy WAS influenced by America, not only by American comic strips but also by cartoons. I think Korky the Cat was definitely inspired by Felix the Cat for example.

@Smurfswacker, Apparently the story in text was an attempt to convince parents that comics had literary merit. Originally balloons were seldom used, but became more regular as the years progressed. I suppose they kept both so that they could still claim the text gave the comics some respectability, but I imagine most kids ignored it and read the balloons instead.

Lew Stringer said...

Something else that's worth mentioning is that in the 1930s American newspapers were used as ballast on ships from America. Some canny people used to salvage the comics sections from the Sunday papers and sell them on the streets in the UK charging 1/2p or a penny. Those comic sections were pure comics of course, using speech ballons and no text captions so it's likely they were a powerful influence on The Dandy as well.

Manic Man said...

of course, I'm not quite sure on today, but Text under panels was pretty common still in the 1990s, where it was mostly used for children's comics (I openly admit I'm a Raggy Dolls Fan.. but i only have 1 issue and an annual *sigh).

Problem is with rumours, is they often exist so people can 'pretend' that they know more then someone else.. a number of years back, i was talking to someone that was trying to impress with his knowledge of Guy Fawkes. Claiming to the world that his real name was Guido Fawkes, but he was called Guy by the English and it was a common mistake.. Until i pointed out to him that he was born Guy, but when he joined the Spanish against the English, he took on a Spanish name, Guido (basically the Spanish venison of Guy). At one time or another, most people are caught be rumours because they are soo common, and so many news/information sites make mistakes and run with them, that we just believe what we are told is the truth..

Diego Jourdan said...

I saw speech balloons in British political cartoons as early as 1817! Another common myth in America is that they were invented by Ocault for The Yellow Kid around 1895... nonsense!

Diego Jourdan said...

Quoting Wikipedia:

"Word balloons containing characters' speech had appeared in political cartoons since at least the 18th century, including some published by Benjamin Franklin.[15] Their origins can be traced back to speech scrolls, painted ribbons of paper which trailed from the mouths of speaking subjects, depicting their words. These were in common European use by the early 16th century and similar devices had appeared in Mayan art between 600 and 900 AD. Outcault's word balloons in the Yellow Kid influenced their basic appearance and use in subsequent newspaper comic strips and comic books."

Zoomy said...

I've got a Happy Mag from 1933 with "Mr Rabbit and his Baby Bunnies" - which is apparently a reprint of Harrison Cady's American Peter Rabbit strip. All speech bubbles and no text, and I assume that's not the only example available to the people of Britain in the early thirties.

http://zoomy.blogspot.co.uk/2011/04/douglas-fairbanks-juniors-gay-love.html

Manic Man said...

ohh.. never quote wiki as fact.. bad move indeed

Mike said...

An example of speech scrolls is people saying "Vivat Rex" or "God save the Kynge" on the frontispiece to the Great Bible of 1539.
More modern-looking balloons (though rather elongated and at funny angles) can be seen on cartoons about the Peterloo Massacre, which happened 'a while' before The Dandy.

And on the subject of silly rumours getting out of hand, somebody complained in spaceship away that British people in 1950 didn't say "OK". Earliest example of "OK" I've seen in a British comic? 1911!

Lew Stringer said...

Hi Mike, You're right, the speech balloon has been around for centuries. However I don't think anyone's been daft enough to claim that The Dandy invented them per se. The claim made by historians was that it was the first British comic to use them (which obviously wasn't the case).

1000MB said...

Theres another myth that needs sorting out. How do oyu read the speech bubbles? Left to Right, top to bottom. Lew do you have a certain way of doing it when drawing them?
Thanks
Jude

Lew Stringer said...

They're just placed in the order that one would naturally read, ie: left to right. (Or right to left in the case of Manga.) Generally, the character who speaks first should be on the left of the panel.

If any comics are confusing it's probably down to the artist (or letterer) not understanding the simple basics of telling a story in comic form.

bobchewie said...

my favoutite comic book artist is Roy Wilson...that look of shock face clutching "LAWCKS !!" is an eternal image for me..

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...